60-year-old male with history of hypertension presented with acute onset of dizziness and diplopia that was diagnosed as a right CN6 palsy by ophthalmology. Initial brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed diffusion restriction isolated to the caudate and putamen leading to a diagnosis of stroke at outside hospital. Exam during neurology follow-up revealed restricted abduction bilaterally, finger-to-nose dysmetria, dysarthria, wide based gait, and normal mentation. Review of initial MRI was unusual for infarct given involvement of three vascular territories and was thought to be characteristic for metabolic or infectious processes including sCJD. Additional workup was notable for positive 14-3-3 and Real-time quaking-induced conversion in cerebrospinal fluid analysis. Repeat MRI showed bilateral basal ganglia and frontal cortex hyperintensities. Patient was diagnosed with probable sCJD by CDC criteria. He was eventually transitioned to palliative care and died 5 months later. Autopsy analysis showed protease-resistant prion protein confirming the diagnosis of sCJD.