Liver function tests were remarkably elevated, and electroencephalography suggested diffuse cortical dysfunction; cognitive and motor delays and abnormal gait were evident. He was diagnosed with ARG1-D through amino acid testing (high arginine/low ornithine) and erythrocyte arginase activity (1% of normal control). He has received standard-of-care management with dietary protein restriction and nitrogen scavengers for >20 years, with ornithine to regenerate the urea cycle, botulinum toxin injections for severe contractures, and medication for seizures. Despite long-term treatment with the best-available care from a multispecialty team, plasma arginine remains high and unstable (initial on-treatment level, ~340 µmol/L; long-term range, 400-500 µmol/L). He has experienced chronic, debilitating progression with development of spastic quadriplegia by age 12, and cognitive impairment, recurrent seizures and vomiting, multiple hospitalizations for hyperammonemia, and hepatomegaly. The patient’s verbal ability and mobility improve when arginine levels trend lower; in contrast, episodes of irritability/aggression and loss of verbal ability coincide with higher arginine levels. Home care is required.