This study was based on serum samples available through the Accelerated Cure Project, from 24 NMOSD (50% APQ4-IgG positive), 70 relapsing remitting (RR) MS, and 83 unaffected controls (UC) who self-identified as non-Hispanic whites. All NMOSD+RRMS cases were immunomodulatory therapy naïve/free (>90 days), <5 years from first symptom, and <2 years from diagnosis. Untargeted metabolomic profiles were generated, and after quality control and normalized/standardization, there were 952 named biochemical traits for analysis. A supervised machine-learning algorithm, Random forests, identified biochemical traits informative for NMOSD in comparison to MS+UC. Multivariable regression analyses characterized associations adjusting for age, sex, smoking status, and body mass index. Receiver operator curves (ROC) evaluated the predictive capacity of top-ranking metabolites.