Conus medullaris syndrome is typically due to extradural compression of the distal spinal cord from disc herniation at the T12-L2 levels. It presents with progressive, disabling, lower extremity weakness, sensory loss, pain, and sphincter dysfunction. Diagnosis is typically made with imaging and electrodiagnostic studies. However, we have noticed a discrepancy between electrodiagnostic findings, which may show only lower lumbosacral root disease, while neuroimaging shows conus compression from thoracic or high lumbar disc herniation. This discrepancy can lead to diagnostic confusion and delay treatment. A similar discrepancy has been reported in patients with upper lumbar stenosis (see Park et al, Muscle and Nerve 2020; 61(5):580-586).