This case illustrates a rare underrecognized cause of progressive thoracic myelopathy with delay in diagnosis of approximately 4 years, that presented as BSS. Though thoracic spine MRI often shows findings suggestive of spinal cord herniation, this finding can be subtle and initially missed, as in this patient. Cases are also missed due to inadequate neurological exam which at time of diagnosis most commonly shows BSS. This patient successfully underwent laminectomy with decompression of spinal cord and repair of anterior dural defect at T3 which was successful in halting the progression of myelopathy.