A 77-year-old woman presented to the emergency department with acute-onset left leg weakness. She was admitted for stroke workup. She endorsed multiple tick bites three weeks prior. In the next two days, she developed quadriplegia and febrile encephalopathy. Broad-spectrum antibiotics were initiated due to concerns for meningitis, and she was intubated and transferred to our Neuro-ICU. A contrasted-MRI showed symmetric T2 FLAIR hyperintensities in the basal ganglia, thalami, frontal lobes and cerebellum with subtle contrast enhancement. CSF analysis revealed 76 cells/cubic mm (lymphocytes) and 130mg/dL protein. Extensive panels for bacterial, viral, and arboviral etiologies were negative. Ultimately, Powassan IgM antibody and PCR in the CSF resulted positive. She underwent tracheostomy and PEG placement and had unfortunately made no improvement by week 6. Subsequently, her family elected for comfort measures, and she was compassionately extubated.