63-year-old woman with mantle cell lymphoma, with recent recurrence, admitted to the hospital for 2 days of mild paraparesis. Symptoms progressed to quadriplegia, encephalopathy and respiratory failure requiring intubation. Initial differential diagnoses and workup included autoimmune causes such as Guillain-Barre syndrome variant, infectious and paraneoplastic causes. CSF notable for albumino-cytologic dissociation with normal MRI brain. West Nile IgM/IgG in serum and CSF and paraneoplastic panels were negative. She was empirically treated with plasma exchange with minimal improvement. Day 12 of hospitalization, repeat MRI brain and spine revealed bilateral FLAIR hyperintensities and diffusion restriction with symmetric involvement of superior cerebellar peduncles, corticospinal tracts and dentate nuclei with enhancement of the ventral cauda equina. Day 16 of hospitalization, CSF metagenomic sequencing detected WNV RNA.