We report a 77-year-old woman who presented with rapidly progressive altered mental status following a brief febrile prodrome. Cerebrospinal fluid studies demonstrated a lymphocytic pleocytosis consistent with aseptic meningitis. Brain MRI revealed an acute lacunar infarct and diffuse cerebral microhemorrhages initially concerning for cerebral amyloid angiopathy. During hospitalization, she developed livedo-like peripheral skin changes prompting evaluation for autoimmune or vasculitic etiologies. Extensive infectious and autoimmune testing was ultimately notable for positive serum and CSF West Nile virus serologies, confirming neuroinvasive WNV infection. Despite transient neurologic improvement, her clinical course deteriorated, and she died following transition to comfort-focused care.