We present a case of A 47-year-old woman with no medical history who presented with painful muscle cramps and stimulus-triggered jerks initially thought to be functional. She was started on paroxetine and tizanidine, after which she developed profound rigidity, tremor, and hyperthermia (Tmax 107 °F) with encephalopathy and autonomic instability contributing to intubation and ICU admission. Despite benzodiazepines and cyproheptadine for suspected serotonin syndrome, she remained encephalopathic with persistent progressive rigidity and myoclonus. Infectious and metabolic workups were negative; MRI brain and EEG were unremarkable. Serum anti–GAD65 antibody came back strongly positive (40 SI; ref <11), CSF showed mild protein elevation (65 mg/dL). She received IV methylprednisolone (5 days), IVIG (5 days), plasma exchange (5 sessions), and rituximab (1g × 2 doses), eventually with gradual improvement.