An 85-year-old male with hypertension, diabetes mellitus, hyperlipidemia, and COPD presented with acute-onset diplopia preceded by episodic left-sided headaches and isolated left abducens nerve palsy. CTA revealed an extra-axial mass at the craniocervical junction displacing the proximal basilar artery posteriorly with severe spinal canal stenosis at C1 causing cord compression. MRI excluded acute ischemia, confirming a T2-hypointense extra-axial retro-odontoid mass consistent with chronic pannus formation. Rheumatological serologies showed mildly elevated ESR (24), normal CRP, and negative rheumatoid factor, yielding low suspicion for active inflammatory arthropathy. Diagnosis was established from characteristic imaging findings in the absence of histopathological confirmation. Patient’s symptoms persisted despite empiric prednisone 60mgQD. Interval MRI demonstrated mild progressive mass enlargement consistent with CPPD-related chronic retro-odontoid pseudotumor with new intracranial extension. Patient referred for neurosurgical evaluation upon discharge.