A 66-year-old woman with history of four embolic-appearing ischemic strokes over one year, including left M1 occlusion treated with thrombolysis and thrombectomy involving multiple bilateral cortical, subcortical, and cerebellar territories, presented with new-onset slurred speech. Brain MRI demonstrated an additional acute infarct. Extensive prior evaluations, including cerebral angiography for large-artery disease, prolonged cardiac rhythm monitoring, cerebrospinal fluid studies for vasculitis, and comprehensive hypercoagulable testing, were unremarkable. A prior transesophageal echocardiogram (TEE) had shown a mobile interatrial septum not meeting criteria for aneurysm. She had received 21-day courses of dual antiplatelet therapy after each cerebrovascular event. During this admission, CT imaging of the abdomen revealed new splenic hypodensities, suggestive of systemic emboli, prompting repeat TEE 9 months after the first one, which demonstrated a hypermobile interatrial septum with aneurysmal dilation measuring 12 mm, without intracardiac thrombus or right-to-left shunt. Anticoagulation with apixaban 5 mg twice daily was initiated for indefinite duration. Over six months of follow-up, she remained free of recurrent cerebrovascular events. Residual deficits include mild cognitive impairment consistent with vascular dementia, reflected by a Montreal Cognitive Assessment score of 18/30 with language and executive dysfunction, precluding return to work.