Twenty-two randomized controlled trials with approximately 15,400 participants were included. Across studies, a graded efficacy hierarchy was observed for 2-hour pain freedom (PF). Atzumi (STS101) achieved PF in 20.4% vs 17.5% with placebo (RR 1.17 [0.95–1.45]) and MBS freedom in 37.0% vs 32.5% (RR 1.14 [0.97–1.34]). Although not statistically superior at 2 hours, Atzumi showed PF rising to ~35% by 3–4 hours with sustained relief beyond 24 hours. In contrast, zavegepant 10 mg IN, ubrogepant 50 mg PO, and rimegepant 75 mg ODT achieved PF RRs of 1.49, 1.52, and 1.46, respectively, while sumatriptan 100 mg PO remained highest (1.88 [1.64–2.15]). SUCRA rankings for 2-hour PF were triptans 91%, gepants 69–73%, and Atzumi 47%, indicating modest early efficacy but durable late response. Safety favored Atzumi, with mild nasal discomfort (8.3%) and dysgeusia (3.7%), and no serious adverse events, compared with higher systemic AEs for oral triptans.