A 41-year-old female presented with headache and a right homonymous inferior quadrantanopsia. MRI revealed a left temporo-parietal lesion with T2 FLAIR hyperintensity, cortical edema, and associated regions of cortical/subcortical diffusion restriction. She was treated as a subacute stroke, etiology undetermined. Interval imaging demonstrated multiple new foci of diffusion restriction within the left hemispheric lesion; this pattern of evolution was felt to be atypical for stroke and favored to be focal inflammatory encephalitis. Extensive investigations culminating in mitochondrial DNA/whole exome sequencing were normal. Repeat imaging 5 years after her initial presentation demonstrated new diffusion restriction in the bifrontal corticomedullary region. Given this new imaging finding NIID was considered and ultimately confirmed with skin biopsy.